Mobiles 'Are Good For Children's Brains'
Evening Standard
Journalist: Isabel Oakeshott
September
22, 2004
The head of Britain's Parent Teacher
Associations was at the centre of an extraordinary row today after
suggesting that mobile phone radiation could improve children's
brains.
Speaking at the Liberal Democrat conference in Bournemouth, David
Butler said he had heard "striking" anecdotal evidence that the heat
from handsets improved pupils' performance at school.
He went on to claim that he had seen no evidence whatsoever that
the phones pose a risk. But his claims fly in the face of government
advice, which discourages the use of mobiles by under 16s.
Many experts
fear that children are particularly vulnerable to low-level
radiation emission from phones and believe they should only use the
handsets in emergencies.
Millions of children now have mobile phones despite persistent
questions about their safety.
Although there is no concrete evidence they cause harm, it is
widely accepted that they heat the head and brain.
Mr Butler made the comments at a meeting on safety issues linked
to mobile phones.
The event was hosted by mobile phone giant O2. Mr Butler shared a
panel with two representatives from the company.
During a question and answer session with Lib-Dem conference
delegates, Mr Butler shrugged off concerns about health risks -
claiming he had heard that the heating effect was good for children.
Questioned by a parent in the audience about the potential
harmful effects of radiation from the handsets, Mr Butler said:
"Actually, from a perspective of pupil performance, it can enhance
things, because that heating effect actually improves the neuron
transfers between neural pathways, and therefore your thinking
ability goes up."
He claimed he had been told this by a British professor, but
would not identify the scientist concerned. He also said he
personally-agreed that the handsetsdid not pose a risk to children.
Mr Butler said: "I take a pragmatic point of view. If I walk out
of this hotel tonight, I endure a health risk. Living carries a
health risk.
"What I am saying is that any parent has to weigh up what is
perceived to be the risk in any situation, and then use whatever
means they feel appropriate to minimise that risk. I personally have
not seen any piece of paper that says to me there is a health risk,
which would give me concern."
He stressed the evidence that heat from mobiles improved
children's performance at school was "anecdotal" but added: "I have
yet to see there is actually evidence that that would create a
health problem.
"But I mean, even frankly if there was, I would still be wanting
to weigh up what someone was telling me about a health problem
against the other benefits that that technology was giving."
Government experts believe the jury is still out on the safety of
handsets. In 2000 the Stewart Report, the largest independent
inquiry in the world into the safety of mobiles, warned that
children should strictly limit their use of mobile phones.
It identified subtle biological effects which might not trigger
illnesses, such as brain tumours, for 20 years.